TRPC Director’s response on FT: Cuban missile crisis not solved by sabre-rattling

TRPC Director’s response on FT: Cuban missile crisis not solved by sabre-rattling

 From Prof John Ure, October 21, 2012 11:38 pm

This response first appeared on the Financial Times, Singapore on 21 Oct 2012

Sir, Philip Zelikow’s version of the resolution of the Cuban missile crisis (“Learn the lesson of Cuba and seize the initiative” FT 19th October 2012) is surprisingly out-of-date for a history dean. Recent releases show quite clearly that this was a behind-the-scenes negotiated settlement whereby the US would withdraw its own nuclear missiles in Italy and Turkey aimed at the Soviet Union in exchange for the Soviet’s not installing their missiles in Cuba. It was a good trade no doubt, but rather more than US President Kennedy manfully staring down Premier Nikita Khrushchev as we were all asked to believe at the time.

In light of this evidence, to conclude as Zelikow does that the “crisis was driven by the side that had the strategic initiative” rather begs the question of which side this was. The Soviets ended up with no less than they started, the US ended up withdrawing their missiles. The lesson would seem to be that negotiations rather than sabre-rattling produce better outcomes, a point to be considered by the US voters.

John Ure, Associate Professor and Director, Telecommunications Research Project, University of Hong Kong

Photo by Anthony Duran on Unsplash

zp8497586rq

Related Articles

Access Alert: Private Sector and Global Health After WHA78

Access Alert: Private Sector and Global Health After WHA78

Major developments at last week’s 78th World Health Assembly (WHA78) indicate next steps for industry: Rebuild Regionally: Redirect advocacy and...

30 May 2025 Opinion
Access Alert: South Africa Signals Positive Change For Connectivity

Access Alert: South Africa Signals Positive Change For Connectivity

The benefits of increasing internet access and broadband connectivity have been estimated and measured by several studies. The World Bank...

28 May 2025 Opinion
Seizing the Opportunity: Asia’s Moment to Reclaim Global Healthcare Talent

Seizing the Opportunity: Asia’s Moment to Reclaim Global Healthcare Talent

A turning point for international talent Historically, the US has benefited from the international “brain drain”, attracting top healthcare talent...

28 May 2025 Opinion
Access Alert: Thailand Proposes New Regulation For ESIM Licensing

Access Alert: Thailand Proposes New Regulation For ESIM Licensing

The Thai National Broadcasting and Telecommunications Commission (NBTC) recently announced a new draft regulation: ‘Criteria for Authorisation to Use Frequency...

28 May 2025 Opinion