TRPC Director on FT, 11 May 2015: “Agriculture secretary’s real concern is about American food exports”

TRPC Director on FT, 11 May 2015: “Agriculture secretary’s real concern is about American food exports”

May 11, 2015 12:10 am

Sir, You report (“US criticises Brussels on global food security”, May 8) that the EU’s decision to allow individual member states to decide for themselves whether to permit the importing of genetically modified crops has been criticised by Tom Vilsack, the US agricultural secretary, ostensibly on the grounds that it would undermine efforts to increase global food security. This is disingenuous on two grounds.

First, there is no lack of food production globally and, climate change notwithstanding, none likely in the foreseeable future. There is a real problem with food distribution and access to food by some of the world’s most impoverished nations, a problem that could be partially solved by redistributing the food glut rather than paying for stocks to be destroyed. But the real solution lies in developing food production capacity in the poorest countries, which could indeed involve genetically modified crops.

Second, Mr Vilsack’s real concern is less to do with global food security and more with American food exports and, as you put it, the threat to future transatlantic trade talks. This highlights the weakness of such talks on two counts. First, portmanteau negotiations are about “trade-offs and pork’’ as compared with bilateral agreements on mutually identified benefits. Second, where are the estimates on how the overall benefits of such a trade agreement would be shared among its participants? US estimates relate only to the overall figure or to those accruing to the US. It may not be a zero-sum game but that does not mean it won’t be less than zero for some.

John Ure

Associate Professor and Director, TRP,

University of Hong Kong

The original article is available here: Agriculture secretary’s real concern is about American food exports [Financial Times, 11 May, 2015]

Related Articles

Access Alert: Enhancing Efficiency in India’s Logistics Through AI and Digital Integration

Access Alert: Enhancing Efficiency in India’s Logistics Through AI and Digital Integration

A recent panel discussion at the Bengaluru Tech Summit 2024 on 20 November 2024 focused on the transformative role of...

29 Nov 2024 Opinion
Access Alert: How Will Deepfake Regulations in APAC Impact Your Business?

Access Alert: How Will Deepfake Regulations in APAC Impact Your Business?

The rise of deepfakes – AI-generated content that manipulates audio, video, or images to create realistic but false representations –...

29 Nov 2024 Opinion
Access Partnership Concludes 2024 with Double Recognition: Best Tech Policy Advisory and Innovative Tech Consultancy of the Year

Access Partnership Concludes 2024 with Double Recognition: Best Tech Policy Advisory and Innovative Tech Consultancy of the Year

London, UK – Access Partnership has celebrated the end of 2024 by winning Best Technology Policy Advisory at The Business...

22 Nov 2024 General
Economic Impact Report: Driving digital growth in Vietnam with Google

Economic Impact Report: Driving digital growth in Vietnam with Google

Vietnam’s economic development journey has been impressive. From one of the world’s lowest-income countries, Vietnam has risen to become a...

14 Nov 2024 General